Isn't that just like the proverbial doctors wife? Sitting in the lap of luxury, sipping water from plastic bottles she will throw away carelessly, watching her offspring dance in the surf in designer swim wear, ignoring Rome as it burns (I am not saying Rome is burning) or issuing the order to "let them eat cake". Who cares about the little people when I am having fun?!
I do have a heart, but this issue is completely overwhelming. Not overwhelming because I am not smart enough to handle the arguments. Overwhelming because it pulls me in so many directions. I don't want people to suffer. I don't want people to go broke from illness. I don't want sick people dying needlessly. I don't want people not seeking medical treatment because they can't afford it. I don't want people to lose their jobs. I don't want doctors to have to consult anyone other than their patients for decision making. I don't want doctors refusing treatment based on ability to pay. And I do care about clean air and clean water for my children and yours.
I love politics, but hate all the political dancing. So much of what happens in our government seems like a complicated waltz, meant to dazzle and convince us that we could never move like they do or that we aren't brilliant enough to understand why they changed directions and paused just so with that little head tilt. In reality a two step could get the job done and everyone could figure it out in one lesson.
I love politics, but hate all the political dancing. So much of what happens in our government seems like a complicated waltz, meant to dazzle and convince us that we could never move like they do or that we aren't brilliant enough to understand why they changed directions and paused just so with that little head tilt. In reality a two step could get the job done and everyone could figure it out in one lesson.
The problem I have had with healthcare (since I became a part of the system in a small way by marrying it) is that patients and doctors don't have a vested interest in working toward true health.
When it comes down to it I am not convinced that we (collectively) care about health that much. What we care about is having someone treat symptoms with as little inconvenience to the ill as possible. Wait times, co-pays, unacceptable - we want on demand medical care. If the cable company can do it why can't health care follow that model?
You could give every American free membership to a local gym, including free babysitting and fancy aluminum water bottles engraved with their name and still the number of people who actually go to the gym wouldn't change much. No one is just that interested in prevention.
We know what we should do to optimize our health but how many people really do it? Stop smoking, eat more fruits and vegetables, lay off the potato chips at 2 am, eat less, exercise more, drink more water and less soda, whole grains, lean meats. It would be difficult to find one American who couldn't name at least 3 things that would immediately improve their health.
We know it, we don't do it. Why? Because it doesn't really matter. Why doesn't it matter? Because no matter what we do to our bodies the miracle that is modern medicine can take care of it. There is a pill/procedure for that!
You can give free screenings, free contraceptives, free prescriptions all day long and still not everyone who needs them will get them. You can give away fruits and vegetables, but they won't get eaten. It is just the way we are.
How can a group of people with different beliefs, and motivations be moved to change the way they think about their own health? That is the key. Not everyone will respond in the same way to whatever carrot is dangled in front of them. Penalties? Taxes? Liens? Public humiliation? Cash rewards? TV's? Gas cards? Movie tickets?
You could give every American free membership to a local gym, including free babysitting and fancy aluminum water bottles engraved with their name and still the number of people who actually go to the gym wouldn't change much. No one is just that interested in prevention.
We know what we should do to optimize our health but how many people really do it? Stop smoking, eat more fruits and vegetables, lay off the potato chips at 2 am, eat less, exercise more, drink more water and less soda, whole grains, lean meats. It would be difficult to find one American who couldn't name at least 3 things that would immediately improve their health.
We know it, we don't do it. Why? Because it doesn't really matter. Why doesn't it matter? Because no matter what we do to our bodies the miracle that is modern medicine can take care of it. There is a pill/procedure for that!
You can give free screenings, free contraceptives, free prescriptions all day long and still not everyone who needs them will get them. You can give away fruits and vegetables, but they won't get eaten. It is just the way we are.
How can a group of people with different beliefs, and motivations be moved to change the way they think about their own health? That is the key. Not everyone will respond in the same way to whatever carrot is dangled in front of them. Penalties? Taxes? Liens? Public humiliation? Cash rewards? TV's? Gas cards? Movie tickets?
My husband operates on obese patients all day long with back problems. Guess what is causing the back problems? All that excess weight!!!! If they would lose the weight they would solve the back problems (in most cases). Guess what is easier than losing weight for back pain? That's right, it is easier to operate (i.e. faster, less inconvenient, no lifestyle change, and very cheap if insured) and if it does not work you can always blame your doctor!
The part that really gets me is that there always has to be a bad guy. Why does it always have to be the doctor? Probably because he is an easy target. Overworked, tired, having been slowly "managed" out of reimbursements, regulations driving up overhead costs, and always promised that it will get fixed this time. It's not getting fixed.
When did we go from honoring and respecting the people who care for our health to demonizing them? This would never happen to a firefighter! It shouldn't happen to anyone. Every contribution to our economy/community should be respected.
Some where the doctor has become the poster child for all that is wrong with healthcare. As if it is their own greed and self-preservation that is causing the problems. Right now we have people deciding what our healthcare system should be, how it should be delivered, who should pay for it, how much providers should get paid, etc who have absolutely no medical experience.
It doesn't give me warm fuzzies thinking that politicians, law makers, and judges are making decisions about healthcare, an area where they have very limited experience and are so very easily swayed by interests that often compete against what is truly best for all the people they claim to serve.
Would you let a mechanic represent you in a court of law. NO!
It doesn't give me warm fuzzies thinking that politicians, law makers, and judges are making decisions about healthcare, an area where they have very limited experience and are so very easily swayed by interests that often compete against what is truly best for all the people they claim to serve.
Would you let a mechanic represent you in a court of law. NO!
The ideal panel of participants in a true reform bill: doctors, patients (insured/uninsured), insurance providers, hospital administrators. Put them in a room for a week, I am sure something useable would come out of it. Let's add a doctors wife to the mix just to make sure it all gets done and no one gets hurt.
THE TAX MAN
Because the Supreme Court decision basically held that this was a taxation issue I thought I would include my two cents here. Who really pays taxes? I have given my complete tax history here in previous posts. Bottom line, I haven't paid federal income taxes in the last 7 years (state taxes is another story). In fact, they keep giving me my money and some back. Maybe some of it was your money... sorry.
So who is going to foot the bill? If it isn't me (and probably isn't you), who?
Well, it will be us (as in me for sure) in 2013. Have you looked at the tax brackets that we are going to be in? Above $218,450 taxable income 36% to 39.6%. That is some serious cash and that is only the federal income tax. Talk about eye opening.
Salaries sound really good, but after taxes..... oh my. The people providing the care will also be the ones paying for it. There are a whole host of other taxes that we will pay, not to mention the expenses that come with practicing medicine. I am thinking of malpractice insurance to the tune of $50-100K per year (or let's just say another 10%), and then employees/facilities..... how will a doctor be able to afford to provide care when everything they have is taxed or spent in the pursuit of practicing medicine?
Salaries sound really good, but after taxes..... oh my. The people providing the care will also be the ones paying for it. There are a whole host of other taxes that we will pay, not to mention the expenses that come with practicing medicine. I am thinking of malpractice insurance to the tune of $50-100K per year (or let's just say another 10%), and then employees/facilities..... how will a doctor be able to afford to provide care when everything they have is taxed or spent in the pursuit of practicing medicine?
And here is where I have to pause and go hmmmmm. Is it fair that some people will pay 39.6% and others will pay absolutely nothing? And this isn't a question I ask just because I am going from the zero tax payer to the crazy tax payer in the near future. I have always wanted to pay something, but that's just me.
I belong to the school of "everyone should have skin in the game". Those who have more should pay more, those with less should pay less, but everyone should pay something (unless you really have nothing). For me it is a matter of principle. There never was a free lunch and there never will be, someone always pays.